Ramit Sethi: Don’t Buy A House Before You Ask This Question

Ramit Sethi: Don't Buy A House Before You Ask This Question

Views:4682|Rating:4.84|View Time:3:29Minutes|Likes:156|Dislikes:5
Real estate might not be the smartest investment for you. Use this test from self-made millionaire and personal finance guru Ramit Sethi to decide.

» Subscribe to CNBC Make It.:

“What if you discovered that real estate isn’t as good of an investment as everybody says?” Sethi asks in an interview with CNBC Make It. Sethi is the author of “I Will Teach You to be Rich” and the founder of GrowthLab.com, an advice site for entrepreneurs.

While many first-time home buyers go into the process assuming that they can turn a tidy profit on any real estate purchase, Sethi says it’s not always so simple. In fact, there are a lot of obstacles and costs that can prevent your real estate purchase from being lucrative if you’re not careful.

“Most people never factor in all the phantom costs, including taxes [and] maintenance,” Sethi says. “They don’t factor in inflation and how that erodes the value of money over time.”

Another important possibility some home-buyers overlook is whether they’d be better off investing in stocks instead of real estate. “In fact, data shows that the stock market typically trounces the performance of real estate as an investment,” Sethi says.

The most important thing you can do before buying a house, Sethi says, is to “run the numbers.”

What you need to do, he says, is take into account your own finances and the average cost of buying versus renting a home in your area. You want to answer this important question: does buying a house make sense for you, where you live, as opposed to renting and putting the money you’d save into the stock market? You need to ask yourself: what’s the best investment for you?

Obviously, stock market performance versus real estate appreciation can depend on a wide range of factors, from buying a home in an up-and-coming neighborhood to investing right before an economic downturn or a boom market. Over time, though, stocks do generally perform better than real estate.

“If you run the numbers, like me, you might discover that for where you live it actually makes no financial sense to buy,” Sethi tells CNBC Make It. “Are there other reasons to buy? Of course. Maybe you want to buy because you want to knock that wall down. Maybe you want to buy because you want your kids to go to a certain school. Fine, but run the numbers.”

Sethi suggests going online to find one of the many “Buy vs. Rent” calculators offered by real estate and personal finance websites. Those sites take into account factors such as where you want to live and how much you can afford to pay (both for a down payment and monthly expenses) to give you an idea of whether it makes more sense for you to buy real estate or rent property.

“Then you want to go a little deeper,” Sethi says. “You want to say, ‘You know what, what can I get in the stock market now?’ Generally we can assume that over the long term, if we invest in a low-cost diversified index fund, we get about 7 percent [annualized returns]. Can you beat that in your area, over time, with real estate appreciation?”

If you do your homework and it doesn’t seem like the real estate you can afford in your area will generate better returns than the stock market over several years — and you don’t mind renting long-term — then you might be better off not being a home-owner, Sethi says.

Most importantly, though, you must do the math before making such a big decision. “For the biggest purchase of your life, you should know all the math and how it plays out 20 years in the future.”

About CNBC Make It.: CNBC Make It. is a new section of CNBC dedicated to making you smarter about managing your business, career, and money.

Connect with CNBC Make It. Online
Get the latest updates:
Find CNBC Make It. on Facebook:
Find CNBC Make It. on Twitter:
Find CNBC Make It. on Instagram:
Find CNBC Make It. on LinkedIn:


Self-made millionaire: Don’t buy a house before you ask yourself this question | CNBC Make It.

Related Posts

8 thoughts on “Ramit Sethi: Don’t Buy A House Before You Ask This Question

  1. lol paying rent for 12 month X 30 years without gaining anything from it is more waste i think. its like throwing giving your money to your landlord making someone richer

  2. Why do people buy? Maybe to have a place to live and bring up a family. The investment is secondary but still important for the future generation, those children who have now grown up and attended their parents burials. It is their inheritance. I bought in 1985 for $230,000 and I sold in 2011 for $2,650,000. Did I make money? I think so, but I didn't run the numbers. This house was mine and my family's home for decades. That was much more important then making money!

  3. I used to think that buying a home wasn't a good investment until I ran the numbers.

    I pulled up a rent vs buy calculator a few months ago and entered all the variables. In my situation buying a home only made sense if I was paying $961 on my rent or less.

    Considering that I was paying nearly $1,400 for a two bedroom in the market I live in it makes sense.

    I highly encourage you to pull up one of these calculators and enter as much accurate information as possible. Everyone's situation is different but we all deserve to make the best financial decisions for ourselves.

  4. I agree with this however, we all need a roof over our heads. Unless you can live with parents/friends long term to reduce costs

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *